anthropologist Melvin Konner.
Jewish folklore holds that intelligence was fostered not by occupation but by channeling the cleverest children to become rabbis. The rabbis were able to have more children, the folklore explanation holds, because they were sought as husbands for the daughters of wealthy families. "Talmudic academies served as systems of selection," writes Konner. "Whatever we think of what was studied, the process culled the best minds in every generation of Jews for more than a thousand years. Rising stars among these bright young men would board with successful merchants, and matches would be made between them and the merchants' daughters."
But the Cochran team gives short shrift to this explanation, saying there were not enough rabbis—only 1% of the population—to make a genetically significant difference. As further proof of their thesis, they cite the fact that the two other main branches of the Jewish community, Oriental Jews and Sephardim, lived mostly under Muslim rulers who often forced them into menial jobs, not the intellect-demanding ones imposed on Ashkenazim. Oriental Jews and Sephardim score similarly to northern Europeans with no elevation in IQ, as would be predicted under the Cochran team's thesis.
Among Ashkenazim, some 15% carry one of the sphingolipid or DNA repair mutations, and up to 60% carry one or other of all the disease mutations. (Most of these diseases are only harmful if a mutated gene is inherited from both parents, and some others are not fully "penetrant," a geneticist's term meaning a person can carry the mutation but doesn't necessarily have the disease.) In summary, the Cochran group has taken two well accepted phenomena—the odd pattern of Ashkenazic Mendelian diseases and the notable intellectual achievement of Ashkenazim—and has attempted to establish a link between them. The argument is necessarily extended, but is carefully developed at each stage. "It's certainly a thorough and well argued paper, not one that can easily be dismissed outright," said Steven Pinker, a cognitive scientist at Harvard. Though several aspects of the argument cross disputed academic territory—it assumes that intelligence is heritable and that IQ scores are a reliable measure of it—it has the virtue of making a clear and testable prediction: that people carrying one of the Ashkenazic mutations should do better than average on IQ tests. As of this writing, the test has not been conducted. Despite the existence of genetic diseases that can be called Jewish, in the broader context Jews are doubtless highly similar to other populations in the west Eurasian or Caucasian branch of the human family. Their genesis as a distinctive group resembles that of Icelanders. Just as Jews appear to be a mixture of Middle Easterners with various European or other Middle Eastern populations, Icelanders also are probably a mix of two Caucasian populations, Norwegians and Celts. Both Jews and Icelanders have practiced endogamy, the necessary step for keeping one's gene pool to oneself, Jews for religious reasons, Icelanders for geographic ones. Icelanders have been genetically separate for 1,000 years, but are still so similar to other Europeans that they can serve as a test bed for discovering European disease genes; Jews have been separate for just 2,000 years longer.
Was this article helpful?